The settlers who first came to Jamestown arrived at a site on the James River in present-day Virginia, about 40 miles inland from Chesapeake Bay, and established their colony on May 14, 1607 (Old Style Julian calendar; May 24 on the modern Gregorian calendar). The three-ship expedition carrying 104 to 105 colonists had made landfall at Cape Henry on April 26, 1607, then sailed upriver and chose a low, marshy peninsula they called Jamestown Island. Two earlier English attempts to plant a colony in North America had already failed, so this date and location were the product of deliberate strategy as much as chance.
The mechanism: why that river bend and that week in May
The Virginia Company of London organized the expedition as a joint-stock venture, and its instructions drove every choice the colonists made. The company wanted a settlement that could be defended against Spanish attack, reachable by oceangoing ships, and far enough inland to avoid the watchful eyes of rival navies.
The chosen site satisfied those requirements unevenly. The peninsula sat on a bend of the James with deep water close to shore, so ships could tie up to trees and unload directly. A narrow neck of land connected the island to the mainland, which made it easy to fortify against overland attack. The spot was also deep inside territory controlled by the Powhatan chiefdom, whose leader, Wahunsunacock, governed roughly 14,000 people across some 30 tributary tribes.
The timing of arrival followed the sailing calendar, not planning for agriculture. Ships left England in December 1606 and took the southern route through the Caribbean, arriving at Cape Henry in late April. By the time the colonists picked their site in mid-May, the spring planting window was largely gone. That delay helped set up the starvation crisis of the following winter.
Wind and tide shaped the final location too. The ships first tried to settle at a spot they named Point Comfort, then moved upriver. A shallow draft and favorable tide let the Susan Constant, Godspeed, and Discovery work their way to the chosen bend. The plain-language version: the colonists picked a defensible riverside spot they could supply by ship, and they got there too late in the season to farm it properly.
Quantified context: 104 people, three ships, one bad winter
The numbers around the first landing explain much of what followed. The fleet carried 104 to 105 colonists, including 40 sailors who later returned to England. The passenger list included roughly 100 men and boys and only a small number of women and children. The ships themselves were modest: the Susan Constant displaced about 120 tons, the Godspeed about 40 tons, and the Discovery a small pinnace of roughly 20 tons.
The site's water quality was the hidden problem. Jamestown Island sat on brackish tidal water, and during the summer the river ran low and salty. Colonists drank from the river and from shallow wells, and dysentery and salt poisoning likely contributed to the death toll. Modern researchers have documented severe drought conditions in the region from roughly 1606 to 1612, which cut fresh water flow and worsened salinity.
The mortality figures are stark. Of the original settlers, roughly 38 were still alive by January 1608. A resupply in 1608 brought a few dozen more, but the winter of 1609 to 1610, remembered as the Starving Time, reduced the population from about 500 to roughly 60. Survivors abandoned the fort in June 1610 and were turned back by a relief fleet only at the mouth of the river.
The timeline below lays out the first year and a half.
| Date (1607–1610) | Event | Colonists present (approx.) |
|---|---|---|
| April 26, 1607 | Landfall at Cape Henry | 104–105 |
| May 14, 1607 (Julian) | Fort and settlement begun at Jamestown | 104–105 |
| June 15, 1607 | Fort completed; John Smith captured by Powhatan | 104–105 |
| January 1608 | First supply arrives; survivors counted | 38 |
| Fall 1608 | Second supply arrives | 200–250 |
| Winter 1609–1610 | Starving Time | Falls from ~500 to ~60 |
| June 1610 | Colony abandoned, then resupplied | ~60 |
The table shows the core pattern: the location made the colony defensible but left it dependent on resupply, and that dependency turned deadly when supply ships were delayed.
Edge cases and the counterintuitive detail
The most counterintuitive fact about the first landing is the calendar itself. The date of May 14, 1607 is recorded in the Old Style Julian calendar, which England still used. Other European powers, including Spain, had already adopted the Gregorian calendar, so a Spanish record of the same events would carry a date 10 days later. That means a modern reader comparing English and Spanish sources for the same week will see two different dates, and neither is wrong. The colony's founding date is also recorded in a handful of ways in secondary literature, so any strict answer to "what was the date" needs to specify which calendar.
Location has similar edge cases. The settlement was not on the mainland but on a peninsula that erosion and sea-level rise have since cut into an island. The site was chosen partly for defense, yet the marshy ground bred disease. A related trap: people sometimes confuse the first landing at Cape Henry with the actual settlement site at Jamestown. Cape Henry was a brief landfall, not a colony.
One more caveat matters for anyone comparing colony dates. Jamestown is often called the first permanent English settlement in North America, but St. Augustine, Florida, was founded in 1565, and the Roanoke colony of 1585 to 1587 failed outright. Jamestown's claim rests on being the first English settlement that endured, not the first European one.
Misconceptions, checked against the record
Several persistent myths distort the date and location question. Checking each against the record sharpens the answer.
The colonists did not choose Jamestown because it was empty or unclaimed. It sat inside Powhatan-controlled territory, and the English presence was contested from the start. The first landing was not the settlement. The colonists reached Cape Henry on April 26, 1607, then spent more than two weeks exploring before beginning the fort on May 14. The date does not appear the same in all sources. Julian and Gregorian reckoning differ by 10 days in the early 1600s, so May 14 and May 24 both describe the same day. John Smith did not command the first landing in the way popular accounts imply. He was one of several leaders, and the colony was governed by a council under company instructions. The site was not chosen for agricultural promise. It was chosen for defense and ship access, which is why food supply failed so quickly.
The plain-language takeaway: the date is well documented if you name the calendar, and the location reflects strategy, not accident.
Practical actions: how to pin down the date and location for yourself
Anyone who needs a defensible answer, whether for a school project or a public-facing piece, can follow a short verification sequence. The steps below use primary and institutional sources rather than secondary summaries.
Check the calendar convention first. State "May 14, 1607, Old Style Julian" and add the Gregorian equivalent of May 24 to avoid ambiguity. Confirm the landfall date separately from the settlement date. Cape Henry, April 26, 1607, is a landing; Jamestown, May 14, 1607, is the founding. Verify the location with coordinates and geography. The fort site sits on Jamestown Island in present-day James City County, Virginia, on the James River. Use institutional sources for population and mortality figures. The National Park Service and the Jamestown Rediscovery archaeological project maintain site-specific records. Treat differing population counts as ranges, not errors. Sources give 104 to 105 initial colonists depending on whether certain sailors are counted.
A useful threshold for judging any secondary source: if it gives a single founding date without noting the calendar or a single colonist count without a range, treat the numbers as simplified. Sources that name the Julian date, the Cape Henry landfall, and the island location are more likely to be accurate.
Limitations of the record and what cannot be concluded
The documentary record of the first landing is narrower than most popular accounts suggest. Much of what is known comes from later recollections, company records, and archaeology rather than a complete contemporary log. The exact day the fort was begun is documented, but the precise week of site selection is less certain.
Population and mortality numbers also carry uncertainty. Different tallies count sailors, boys, and later arrivals differently, so figures like 104 or 105 are best treated as ranges. The Starving Time death toll is reconstructed from survivor accounts and is approximate.
What cannot be concluded from the evidence is how much of the colony's failure was due to the site itself versus supply failures, leadership conflict, and drought. All four factors appear in the record, and assigning precise shares to each is not possible. Similarly, the exact degree to which brackish water versus disease versus malnutrition drove deaths remains an active question in the archaeology and history literature.
The most defensible answer stays narrow and specific. The first settlers arrived at Cape Henry on April 26, 1607, and began the settlement at Jamestown Island on the James River on May 14, 1607, Old Style Julian, which corresponds to May 24 on the Gregorian calendar.