The starting quarterback for the Cleveland Browns to open the 2025 season is Joe Flacco, the 40-year-old veteran whom the team re-signed in the offseason; rookie draft picks Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders sit behind him on the depth chart, and Kenny Pickett was traded to Las Vegas in June. Flacco opened 2024 as Cleveland's Week 1 starter before Deshaun Watson replaced him in October.
Flacco's presence at the top says less about his arm than it does about the constraints on the 2025 roster: a massive dead-money charge from the Watson contract, an offensive line rebuilt after a rough 2024, and a coaching staff determined not to hand a rookie a losing situation. This explainer walks through the mechanics of how the depth chart was built, the arc of Cleveland's quarterback churn since 1999, and the flags that could flip the starter at any point.
How the depth chart was assembled
The answer begins in 2022, when the Browns traded three first-round picks and a package of later selections to Houston for Deshaun Watson and then signed him to a fully guaranteed five-year, USD 230 million contract. That contract, structured with outsized signing-bonus proration and later restructures, created cap charges that made walking away prohibitively expensive. When Watson suffered a season-ending Achilles rupture in October 2024 and then re-tore it during rehabilitation, the team's calculus changed: for 2025, the dead-money cap hit absorbed by releasing or designating him after June 1 is enormous relative to the cap ceiling.
The result is that Cleveland entered the 2025 offseason with only a modest amount of effective cap space. Eight draft picks, including two late first-rounders (Gabriel at 94th overall was actually a third-round pick; Sanders went in the fifth round, 144th overall), gave the team cheap labor at the position but no veteran assurance. The front office chose a stabilizing move: re-signing Flacco to a team-friendly one-year deal, giving the locker room an adult in the room while the rookies develop.
The mechanics matter because NFL depth charts are not meritocracies in a vacuum. Coaches weigh: practice performance, opponent matchup, protection quality, and public relations. Flacco's 2024 run with Cleveland (he started seven games before Watson returned) produced a passer rating in the high 80s with a sub-.500 record, but he protected the ball reasonably well and knew the offense. The coaching staff, entering a make-or-break year, preferred continuity over experimentation.
The number behind the decision: dead money
The most consequential number in Cleveland's quarterback picture is the dead cap attributable to Watson's contract in 2025. Precisely because of the way the deal was restructured, the post-June 1 release designation spreads the bonus proration across 2025 and 2026 rather than accelerating it all into one season. Even so, the 2025 charge runs well into eight figures and consumes a large fraction of Cleveland's adjusted cap. Estimating precisely is risky without the league's internal cap accounting; the qualitative point is that the charge is one of the largest single-player dead-cap hits in the league this season.
That number cascades. Cleveland had to prioritize affordable extensions for core players and could not win a bidding war for a bridge quarterback like Sam Darnold or Aaron Rodgers. It also meant that any trade for a veteran would likely require Cleveland to absorb salary, which the cap sheet could not support. Cheap rookie contracts became the only viable path to adding two quarterbacks in one draft.
A second number: Flacco's 2025 base salary and incentives are modest relative to his career earnings — a one-year deal in the low eight figures at most, with playing-time and performance escalators. For the Browns, that is a bridge price, not a long-term commitment.
A timeline of the position since 1999
Cleveland's quarterback history is a case study in how instability compounds. The table below traces the eras.
| Era | Starter(s) | Defining event |
|---|---|---|
| 1999–2004 | Tim Couch, Kelly Holcomb | Expansion team, Couch drafted first overall |
| 2005–2009 | Charlie Frye, Derek Anderson, Brady Quinn | Anderson's 2007 Pro Bowl season, then regression |
| 2010–2012 | Colt McCoy, Seneca Wallace, Brandon Weeden | Weeden drafted at 28, released in 2014 |
| 2013–2016 | Brian Hoyer, Johnny Manziel, Josh McCown, Cody Kessler | Manziel's off-field spiral, McCown's bridge role |
| 2017–2018 | DeShone Kizer, Tyrod Taylor, Baker Mayfield | 0-16 season, Mayfield drafted first overall |
| 2019–2021 | Baker Mayfield | Playoff win in 2020, shoulder injury in 2021 |
| 2022–2024 | Deshaun Watson, Jacoby Brissett, Flacco, Dorian Thompson-Robinson | Watson trade, suspension, injuries |
| 2025 | Joe Flacco (opening starter), Dillon Gabriel, Shedeur Sanders | Watson dead money, rookie development |
The pattern: since 1999, the Browns have started more than 30 different quarterbacks, and no starter has held the job for more than four consecutive seasons. The 2025 setup is consistent with that history — a bridge starter with developmental backups — but the cap math makes it more deliberate than the chaos of earlier eras.
Red flags that could change the starter
Flacco suffers a significant injury or shows sharp decline in arm strength during the first month. The offensive line allows pressure rates above roughly 40% through the first four games, forcing the staff to protect a rookie instead of exposing him. Gabriel or Sanders outperforms Flacco decisively in joint practices or preseason games, creating public pressure. The Browns start 0-4 or worse, making playoff odds negligible and turning the season into an evaluation exercise. Watson's rehabilitation reaches a point where the team considers activating him late in the season, reopening a controversy the front office wants to avoid.
Each of these is a real trigger, not a hypothetical. The first two are the most likely to force a change before midseason; the last is the most politically fraught.
What the comparison actually looks like
The four quarterbacks on Cleveland's 2025 roster differ sharply in experience, contract structure, and risk profile. The table below compares them.
| Player | 2025 cap treatment | Experience | Primary risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Flacco | One-year deal, modest base | 17 seasons | Age-related decline, mobility |
| Dillon Gabriel | Rookie contract (third round) | Rookie | Processing speed, NFL pressure |
| Shedeur Sanders | Rookie contract (fifth round) | Rookie | Decision-making under duress, sack avoidance |
| Deshaun Watson | Large dead cap charge | 8 seasons | Achilles rehab, legal exposure |
Flacco's cap number is the lowest of the four relative to his expected snaps; Watson's is the highest relative to his expected snaps, since he may not play at all. Gabriel's and Sanders' cap hits are minimal, which is why the team could afford to draft both.
The counterintuitive detail
Most fans assume the highest-drafted quarterback on the roster gets the first shot when the starter falters. In Cleveland's case, the opposite is more likely. Because Gabriel was drafted earlier (third round, 94th overall) than Sanders (fifth round, 144th overall), Gabriel holds the nominal backup job — but the coaching staff has signaled that the two will compete openly in training camp. More importantly, the staff may prefer to start the rookie who shows the best command of the protection scheme, not the one with the higher draft pedigree. Sanders' college tape showed exceptional poise in structure but a tendency to hold the ball; Gabriel's tape showed quicker decisions but a smaller frame. The staff's evaluation criteria are likely to weigh sack avoidance heavily given the line's 2024 struggles.
A second counterintuitive point: Flacco's experience is not purely an asset. His 2024 film showed a quarterback who could still throw with anticipation but struggled to escape pressure and was reluctant to scramble. Against defenses that generate quick pressure — Pittsburgh, Baltimore, and the Jets in 2025 — the staff may prefer a mobile rookie even if the rookie is less polished.
Practical actions for fans tracking the job
Watch the first two preseason games for snap distribution: if Flacco plays fewer than 10 snaps, the staff is signaling a competition. Track pressure rate and sack rate in the first four regular-season games; a pressure rate above 40% is the threshold at which coaches typically reconsider protection-heavy veterans. Monitor injury reports on Wednesdays and Fridays for Flacco's shoulder and ankle status. Follow beat reporting on joint practices with the Eagles and Vikings, where depth-chart reps are often decisive. Note the team's record after Week 6; a 2-4 or worse start historically triggers evaluation-mode decisions.
Limitations and what cannot be known
The 2025 depth chart is a snapshot, not a fixed fact. Flacco's age (40) makes injury risk materially higher than for a quarterback in his late twenties, and the rehabilitation timeline for Watson is uncertain. The precise cap figures depend on restructures and incentives not fully public, so any dead-money number should be treated as an estimate. Finally, coaching decisions are influenced by factors — owner preferences, locker-room dynamics, media pressure — that no external analysis can fully capture.
For high-stakes decisions about your own health, finances, or legal situation, this article is general educational information only; it is not a diagnosis, treatment plan, legal opinion, or investment recommendation, and it does not promise any outcome. Consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your circumstances, and if you are in immediate danger, contact local emergency services.